While fans of the dark, supernatural world of John Constantine have been clamoring for a sequel ever since the 2005 film Constantine, recent whispers from Hollywood suggest that Constantine 2 may finally be on the horizon—though nothing has been officially confirmed just yet.

Keanu Reeves, who became synonymous with the role of the occult detective, is reportedly in talks to reprise his role as John Constantine, the chain-smoking, demon-fighting antihero. Though various rumors have circulated over the years, sources close to the project hint that there could be something more substantial brewing behind the scenes.

Plot details for Constantine 2 remain shrouded in secrecy, but early speculation points to a continuation of the first film’s exploration of the balance between Heaven, Hell, and the mortal realm. One source claims that the sequel will dive deeper into the personal and psychological turmoil Constantine faces, as he grapples with the consequences of his actions and the torment of his damned soul.