In a seismic shift within the NHL landscape, Conor McDavid’s impending contract negotiations could spell disaster for Auston Matthews’ future with the Toronto Maple Leafs. Expected to command a staggering $17.5 million annually—potentially the highest salary in league history—McDavid’s new deal is poised to reset the market for star players, leaving Toronto in a precarious position regarding their own superstar.
As McDavid, the captain of the Edmonton Oilers, approaches the end of his current contract in 2026, the pressure mounts. His next deal, rumored to be between $16 million and $17.5 million per year, could have ripple effects throughout the league. Matthews, currently earning $13.25 million annually, is set for a significant payday when his contract expires in 2028, but McDavid’s record-setting salary could push his asking price into the stratosphere—potentially $18 million or more.
The implications are staggering. With the NHL salary cap projected to rise to $95.5 million by the 2025-2026 season, the financial landscape is shifting rapidly. If McDavid’s contract sets a new precedent, the Maple Leafs may find themselves unable to retain Matthews without making drastic roster changes or trading away key players. The fear among fans is palpable; if Matthews’ demands soar, Toronto could be forced to contemplate a future without their captain.
Moreover, McDavid’s rumored preference for a short-term contract—potentially spanning just two to four years—could lead to further complications. A short deal would allow him to re-enter the market when the salary cap increases, potentially earning even more. This situation creates a ticking clock for the Maple Leafs, who must weigh their options carefully. Should they extend Matthews early, risking financial strain, or wait and gamble on his future performance?
The stakes could not be higher. As the hockey world watches closely, McDavid’s contract negotiations are about more than just one player; they could redefine how contracts are structured across the league. For the Maple Leafs, the urgency is clear: they must act decisively to secure their future, or risk losing one of the game’s brightest stars. All eyes are on McDavid, and the consequences of his decisions could shape the NHL for years to come.